Food sanitation, drinking-water treatment, and wastewater disposal have been
mainstays of public health since the earliest times. As health departments were
given the added responsibility of guarding against toxins in the broader
environment, these regulatory functions were grouped into environmental
health. Most public health orders are directed at environmental health
problems. Because they affect property, not persons, they do not pose the
difficult issues of personal freedom that arise with the rarer communicable
disease control orders.
Environmental health regulations pose two central legal questions: whether the
government owes compensation to the owners of regulated property, and
under what circumstances health officers can enter private premises to look for
public health law violations. Both questions arise from the U.S. Constitution,
which requires that property owners be paid a fair price for property taken for
public purposes and prohibits unreasonable searches and seizures. The difficult
problem is deciding if the government has searched the property unreasonably
or has taken the value of the property for which the owner must be
compensated.