College students face many of the same health problems as younger students,
but the legal problems are more complicated. The college student is often
away from home and without the usual support system in times of illness.
Dormitories do not provide chicken broth and dry toast to every student with
the flu. They may even be the source of food poisoning, measles, epidemic
respiratory disease.
As in other school settings, the physician’s duty is to the patient, not the
institution. If the college food service is a frequent source of food poisoning,
the college physician should insist that something be done to correct the
problem. Physicians must not change the diagnosis from food poisoning to
gastroenteritis of unknown origin to avoid political problems. They should work
with the college administration to address particular health problems, but
medical judgments should not be compromised for administrative convenience.
Issues of consent and confidentiality do not change when the patient is a
college student. All residential schools should have a power of attorney to
consent to medical care for students who are still minors. It is risky to assume
that they will all stay healthy until they reach their majority. This is especially
important for minors who are far from home, particularly international
students. It is also useful for students who are not minors to consider a power
of attorney to consent to medical care if their parents are not readily available
or if they do not want their parents involved in their medical care decisions.
College physicians must respect the students’ confidentiality. The fact that a
parent may be paying the tuition or medical bills does not give the parent the
right to medical information about a child who is not a minor. At the same
time, the parents of a college student have the reasonable expectation that
they will be contacted if the student is in trouble or requires significant medical
care. The university should require students to sign a waiver that allows it to
contact the student’s parents in such circumstances. (The university should
allow exceptions for students who are estranged from their parents.) For
certain kinds of care, such as treatment for drug abuse or venereal disease,
the information should be protected unless the student requests that parents
be notified. However, students must understand that they may have to pay for
the care if they want to keep it confidential. The physician should explain to
students who ask that something not appear on a bill that few parents and no
insurance company will pay for unspecified services.