Home

Climate Change Project

Table of Contents

Courses

Search


<< >> Up Title Contents

THE CRUZAN CASE

On June 15, 1990, the U.S. Supreme Court rendered its long-awaited decision in the Cruzan "right-to-die" case. The actual law established by this case is very narrow and is only tangentially related to the termination of life support. This decision has discomfited many physicians because it does not establish an easy-to-administer, national standard for the termination of life support. Cruzan is an important decision because it clarifies several issues surrounding the termination of care for incompetent patients. While it does not resolve the dilemmas posed by incompetent patients who have not properly formalized their wishes concerning continued care, Cruzan may prove to be a wise compromise for a difficult problem.

The specific facts of the Cruzan case are compelling: a young woman, brain injured in an automobile accident, was trapped in a persistent vegetative state for years. Brain atrophy made recovery or rehabilitation hopeless, and her family requested that her life support be terminated, but the state refused.

Cruzan is a hard case, and hard cases make bad law because they tempt judges and juries to help the injured party rather than follow the law. Physicians are not strangers to hard cases. Every birth injury case tempts juries to help the baby by disregarding the legal standard for proof of malpractice. The facts in Cruzan call out to the court to ignore the traditional rule of patient autonomy and allow the family to terminate a patient's life support. This would be a good result in Cruzan, but would it best serve the needs of future patients and their health care providers?



<< >> Up Title Contents

Law and the Physician Homepage
Copyright 1993 - NOT UPDATED

The Law, Science & Public Health Law Site
The Best on the WWW Since 1995!
Copyright as to non-public domain materials
See DR-KATE.COM for home hurricane and disaster preparation

See WWW.EPR-ART.COM for photography of southern Louisiana and Hurricane Katrina
Professor Edward P. Richards, III, JD, MPH - Webmaster