THE TECHNOLOGICAL IMPERATIVE VERSUS COST CONTAINMENT
The underlying paradigm of critical care medicine is the technological
imperative: "the desire of physicians to do everything that they have been
trained to do, regardless of the benefit cost ratio."[229] This approach evolved during the period of
fee-for-service reimbursement when there was no reason to contain costs. Since
CCU care is disproportionately expensive, reducing its cost is central to all
managed care schemes.
The Office of Technology Assessment case study on intensive care units
listed the following as factors that led to a treatment imperative in intensive
care medicine:
1)
The focus on high technology, which obscures the underlying
rational for treatment;
2)
The nature of ICU illnesses, which often require technologically
oriented treatment just to keep the patient comfortable. This blurs the
distinction between palliative treatment and definitive treatment;
3)
The moral climate which stresses erring on the side of more
treatment, rather than less;
4)
Diffusion of decision making responsibility;
5)
The problem that many patients are not able to make their wishes
known;
6)
The practice of so called "defensive medicine";
7)
A payment environment which encouraged ICU care in general and
procedure oriented care in specific; and
8)
The difficulty of projecting the probability of recovery for
specific ICU patients.[230]
[229]Fuchs VR: Who Shall Live? Health,
Economics and Social Choice. 1974.
[230]Berenson RA: Intensive care units
(ICUs): Clinical outcomes, costs, and decision making. (Health Technology Case
Study 28) prepared for the Office of Technology Assessment, U.S. Congress,
OTA-HCS-28, Washington, DC, Nov 1984 at 12.
The Medical and Public
Health Law Site
The Best on the WWW Since 1995!
Copyright as to non-public domain materials
See DR-KATE.COM for home disaster preparation
Edward P. Richards, III, JD, MPH Webmaster
